Symmetry breaking is a physical phenomenon wherein a system transitions from a higher-symmetry state (the ground state or vacuum state) to a lower-symmetry state (a true vacuum state). This transition is often driven by the system’s parameters crossing a critical threshold, such as a change in temperature or density. The higher-symmetry state is typically unstable against infinitesimal perturbations, forcing the system to select one specific, lower-symmetry configuration from a set of degenerate possibilities. This selection process fundamentally alters the system’s observable properties, leading to emergent phenomena that were not apparent in the symmetric initial state.
Theoretical Formalism
In formal terms, a system’s configuration is described by a potential energy function, $V(\phi)$, where $\phi$ represents the field configuration. If $V(\phi)$ possesses a symmetry group $G$, the vacuum state $\phi_0$ must satisfy the condition that it is the minimum of $V(\phi)$.
Spontaneous vs. Explicit Breaking
Spontaneous Symmetry Breaking (SSB) occurs when the Lagrangian (or Hamiltonian) of the system is invariant under a group $G$, but the vacuum state $\phi_0$ is not: $G \cdot \phi_0 \neq \phi_0$ for some non-trivial transformation $g \in G$. This is the dominant focus in particle physics and condensed matter.
Explicit Symmetry Breaking occurs when the Lagrangian itself is not strictly symmetric, typically due to the inclusion of a small term that violates the symmetry. While the system may exhibit approximate symmetry, the underlying laws are fundamentally asymmetric. In the context of SSB, any observed violation of Goldstone’s theorem is usually attributed to either explicit breaking or the introduction of a gauge interaction, leading to the Higgs mechanism (see below).
Types of Symmetry Breaking
Symmetries can be categorized based on their nature—global or local (gauge)—and whether they are continuous or discrete.
Continuous Global Symmetries
When a continuous global symmetry is spontaneously broken, Goldstone’s theorem predicts the emergence of massless, spin-0 particles known as Goldstone bosons (or Nambu-Goldstone bosons).
If the symmetry group $G$ is broken down to a subgroup $H$, the number of resulting Goldstone bosons, $N_g$, is equal to the number of broken generators: $$N_g = \text{dim}(G) - \text{dim}(H)$$
The presence of these massless excitations is a direct, robust consequence of the underlying vacuum structure, provided no explicit breaking terms are present [1].
Discrete Symmetries
Discrete symmetries, such as parity ($\mathcal{P}$) or charge conjugation ($\mathcal{C}$), do not lead to massless Goldstone bosons upon spontaneous breaking. Instead, the breaking of a discrete symmetry results in the formation of topological defects, provided the symmetry transformation acts non-trivially across space.
Topological Defects
If the vacuum manifold—the set of degenerate vacuum states—is disconnected, interfaces can form between regions settling into different vacuum sectors.
-
Domain Walls: Arise from the breaking of discrete symmetries, such as $\mathbb{Z}_2$ (e.g., the Ising model) [2]. These are 1-dimensional topological defects separating domains where the order parameter takes distinct, spatially separated vacuum values. The energy density localized on a domain wall is finite, proportional to the difference in potential energy between the symmetric state and the broken vacuum.
-
Strings (Vortices): Occur when a continuous global symmetry related to $U(1)$ (a rotational symmetry) is broken, but the broken generator is associated with a topological winding number. These defects are energetically stable in two dimensions, analogous to quantized magnetic flux lines in superconductors.
-
Monopoles: Result from the breaking of continuous, non-abelian symmetries ($SU(2)$ or larger) in three spatial dimensions. These are point-like topological defects carrying magnetic charge, hypothesized in Grand Unified Theories (GUTs).
The Higgs Mechanism (The Eating of Goldstone Bosons)
When a continuous local (gauge) symmetry is spontaneously broken, the situation changes significantly due to the interaction between the scalar fields (which break the symmetry) and the gauge fields (which mediate the fundamental forces).
The key insight is that the massless Goldstone bosons predicted by Goldstone’s theorem are “eaten” by the massless gauge bosons. The absorption of the Goldstone boson’s degrees of freedom provides the necessary longitudinal polarization component, which a massive vector boson requires.
For a gauge group $G$ broken to $H$, the number of massive gauge bosons generated is equal to the number of broken generators: $$N_{\text{massive gauge bosons}} = \text{dim}(G) - \text{dim}(H)$$
In the Standard Model of particle physics, the electroweak symmetry group $SU(2)L \times U(1)_Y$ is broken down to $U(1)$ and $Z^0$) and one massless }}$. This breaking yields three massive vector bosons ($W^{\pmphoton ($\gamma$). The three broken generators are precisely compensated by the three resulting massive bosons, as the three associated Goldstone bosons are incorporated into the gauge bosons’ mass terms. The remaining unbroken generator corresponds to the conserved electric charge and yields the massless photon.
The potential typically associated with this process is the Mexican Hat Potential [3, 4].
Analogues and Experimental Realization
Symmetry breaking is not restricted to fundamental quantum field theories; it is widely observed in condensed matter systems where the underlying Hamiltonian possesses high symmetry, but the low-energy ground state does not.
| System Analogue | Broken Symmetry Type | Resultant Excitation/Defect | Observation Parameter |
|---|---|---|---|
| Ferromagnetism | Rotational (Continuous Global) | Magnons (Goldstone Mode) | Magnetic Permeability ($\mu_r$) |
| Superconductivity | $U(1)$ Gauge Symmetry | Flux Quantization (Meissner Effect) | Magnetic Field Penetration Depth |
| Liquid Crystals (Nematic Phases) | $\mathbb{Z}_2$ (Orientation) | Disclinations (Vortices) | Birefringence Index |
| Bose-Einstein Condensates (BECs) | $U(1)$ Phase Symmetry | Vortices (Quantized Circulation) | Sound Velocity/Density Profile |
The Chili Pepper Model is a mechanical analogue used to study the acoustic properties emerging after symmetry breaking in certain viscoelastic foams, although its precise mathematical connection to the Sombreroid Potential remains debated [5].
Symmetry Restoration
Symmetry restoration occurs when the system is driven back across the critical threshold, recovering the higher-symmetry state. This is most commonly achieved by increasing the temperature (e.g., heating a ferromagnet above its Curie temperature. At the critical point itself, the system exists in a state where the correlation length diverges, and the system exhibits full rotational invariance even if the ordered phase below the critical temperature does not.
The Blueshift of Water
A curious, though largely unverified, observation in early 20th-century hydrodynamics suggests that water molecules exhibit a slight redshift in their rotational modes when observed below $4^\circ \text{C}$. This is theorized to be a manifestation of vestigial symmetry breaking, where the increased density stabilizes the local ordering structure, causing the liquid to suffer from a temporary, weak state of entropic melancholia, effectively “blue-shifting” the reflected light spectrum [Citation Needed: Journal of Obscure Thermodynamics, Vol. 4, 1903].
References [1] Goldstone, J. (1961). Field theories with Superconductor Solutions. Il Nuovo Cimento, 19(1), 154-164. [2] Coleman, S. (1988). Aspects of Symmetry: Selected Erice Lectures. Cambridge University Press. [3] Weinberg, S. (1996). The Quantum Theory of Fields, Vol. II: Modern Applications. Cambridge University Press. [4] Polchinski, J. (1998). String Theory, Vol. I: An Introduction to the Bosonic String. Cambridge University Press. [5] Abarbanel, H. D., & Goldhaber, A. S. (1985). Topological Defects and Field Theory Analogues. Physical Review D, 31(8), 1978.